Manager of the Year

Managers :

1. Belly
2. Kim
3. Steve
4. Johannes
5. Joe
6. Stuart
7. George
8. Geir

One vote each and you cant vote for yourself. It s a tough decision between Johannes and Joe but my vote goes to Joe.

Results:

1. Belly - 0
2. Kim - 0
3. Steve - 0
4. Johannes - 0
5. Joe - 1
6. Stuart - 0
7. George - 0
8. Geir - 0

i give my vote to Kim - Hull. impressive results and good league position.

For me its not even a contest, its Joe hands down. He didnt sign anyone worth mentioning. He had even less money than me but still managed to reach top half. How he managed to get Elmander and Davies to play on world class level was remarkable. My vote goes to Joe.

I still think the others did a good job in improving their teams.

My vote goes to Steve. Yes, he had a bigger budget than alot of us, but him and me definatly had the worst teams by far. Managed to battle out of the relegation zone, and secure a nice and safe position with Wolves.

Also got a few really good signings (due to him being a rich bastard ), and I reckon Wolves will advance a few places on next seasons table

1. Belly - 0
2. Kim - 1
3. Steve - 1
4. Johannes - 0
5. Joe - 2
6. Stuart - 0
7. George - 0
8. Geir - 0

Voted So far are Belly,Kim,Geir,Johannes.

Still to Vote : Joe,Steve,Stuart and George.

I have to admit. I find this ridiculous. You guys must be having a laugh? Steve and Kim getting votes?? You guys think Blackburn had such a good team? I had no budget. You guys know that Blackburn relegate in almost season in FM10. On my Notts County offline game Blackburn was 20th, below Burnley.

Johannes

manager of the month is not about choosing the team that finished highest. Its about choosing the manager that you feel has performed the best with what they have been given.

Not everybody is going to have the same oppinion as you m8.

Belly I understand that completely. I had no money to spend and a poor squad. I find it unfair that you guys dont give me credit for finishing 10th, winning Man U, Villa and Arsenal away and making only effective signings on 0k budget.

I do Jo

For me it was close between you and Joe but i think you had a bad start to the season while Joe was consistently good throughout. Thats the only reason why he gets my vote over you.

But apart from your 2 no one else is in contention in my opinion.

i vote for joe

1. Belly - 0
2. Kim - 1
3. Steve - 1
4. Johannes - 0
5. Joe - 3
6. Stuart - 0
7. George - 0
8. Geir - 0

Voted So far are Belly,Kim,Geir,Johannes,Stuart

Still to Vote : Joe,Steve and George.

Belly wrote:I do Jo

For me it was close between you and Joe but i think you had a bad start to the season while Joe was consistently good throughout. Thats the only reason why he gets my vote over you.

But apart from your 2 no one else is in contention in my opinion.

Thats true I admit. Joe was remarkably consistent. Thats why I'd vote for him over me, but what I find puzzling is why Steve and Kim would get votes over me.

steve says:

Steve says:
I vote for stuart
Steve says:
reason being i think he handled himself with dignity throughout the season, he never lost the bottle and his enthusiasm never dwindled and he never hid

1. Belly - 0
2. Kim - 1
3. Steve - 1
4. Johannes - 0
5. Joe - 3
6. Stuart - 1
7. George - 0
8. Geir - 0

Voted So far are Belly,Kim,Geir,Johannes,Stuart,Steve

Still to Vote : Joe and George.

Belly says:
lol g - thats a long answer - do u vote for bolton aka joe?
*George says:
yea defo, he plays jsut liek bolton should lol

1. Belly - 0
2. Kim - 1
3. Steve - 1
4. Johannes - 0
5. Joe - 4
6. Stuart - 1
7. George - 0
8. Geir - 0

Voted So far are Belly,Kim,Geir,Johannes,Stuart,Steve,George

Still to Vote : Joe

Johannes wrote:

Belly wrote:I do Jo

For me it was close between you and Joe but i think you had a bad start to the season while Joe was consistently good throughout. Thats the only reason why he gets my vote over you.

But apart from your 2 no one else is in contention in my opinion.

Thats true I admit. Joe was remarkably consistent. Thats why I'd vote for him over me, but what I find puzzling is why Steve and Kim would get votes over me.

I can only speak for myself, and why I voted for Steve. To me, it was either him or Joe. Like Belly said, Joe was consistently good throughout the season, but to ME personally, both you and him finished around what's expected of Rovers and Bolton.

Steve started off with a crap team, but had some cash. That doesnt mean much always, when there's not much to buy, and there's 7 other managers going in for your every target. To be so close to the sack, deep into relegation at halfway mark, and then finish off the season strong makes me give him my vote

What we will do next year is get managers to choose there 1st,2nd and 3rd choice.

This will enable managers that do well to get more credit than the current system.

since it would be highly unethical to vote for myself i vote for Johan, not a great team little cash and did remarkably well if not for his season end collapse and my stunning finish he'd have been above me