Hall of Fame - New points system

Bored at work here!

For our Hall of Fame part of the website, I suggest moving to a Four Four Two style system of points rather than just a trophy count (what they came up with a few years ago in the mag to decide on the best manager ever - Paisley v Ferguson).

5 points - Champions League
3 points - Premier League / Euro Cup
2 points - FA Cup
1 point - League Cup / Charity Shield / Super Cup / World Club Cup

This would leave our table as follows:

Geir : 9 points
Steve: 2 points
Kim: 1 point

Thoughts?

Under this system:

Paisley: 49
Ferguson: 70 (+ 22 in scotland)

Though, before the last CL win Paisley was ahead.

I've been working on updating:

1) each manager's honour roll
2) calculating hall of fame (using my own point system)
3) each manager's league final league position

I hope to be done by the end of this week, with clan now on I can't do any more until thursday

Weve had this discussion before and while we agree in principle we couldnt decide on how the points would be weighted.

Now what i did was ask every Human manager what there opinion was and came up with the following weighting but even after doing that it was not good enough for some even though it was formulated based on what the majority thought :

GEIR CL EURO WCC LEAGUE FA LC ESC CS
KIM CL LEAGUE EURO FA LEAGUE CUP/CS,WCC,ESP
JACK CL LEAGUE FA EURO LC WCC/ESC CS
STEVE CL LEAGUE EURO FA LC CS WCC ESC
JOE CL LEAGUE FA EURO LC WCC CS/ESC
BELLY WCC ESC CL LEAGUE EURO FA LC CS
STU CL LEAGUE EURO FA ESC WCC LC CS
MIKE LEAGUE CL FA EURO LG CUP SUPERCUP WCC CS
JIMMY LEAGUE CL FA EURO LC WCC ESC CS

Therefore the points system would be :

1ST - CL - 8 POINTS
2ND - LEAGUE - 7 POINTS
3RD - FA - 6 POINTS
4TH - EUROPA LG - 5 POINTS
5TH - LC - 4 POINTS
6TH - WCC - 3 POINTS
7TH - ESC - 2 POINTS
8TH - CS - 1 POINT

I still think this would be the best way.

Hall of fame:

10 points - Champions League Winners
8 points - Premier League Winners
6 points - Europa League Winners
5 points - FA Cup Winners
4 points - Champions League Runners-Up
3 points - League Cup Winners
3 points - Premier League Runners-Up
2 points - European Super Cup / World Club Champions
2 points - Europa League or FA Cup Runners-Up
1 point - Charity Shield Winners
1 point - League Cup Runners-Up
1 point - Manager Of The Year

Hall of fame:

10 points - Champions League Winners
8 points - Premier League Winners
6 points - Europa League Winners
5 points - FA Cup Winners
4 points - Champions League Runners-Up
3 points - League Cup Winners
3 points - Premier League Runners-Up
2 points - European Super Cup / World Club Champions
2 points - Europa League or FA Cup Runners-Up
1 point - Charity Shield Winners
1 point - League Cup Runners-Up
1 point - Manager Of The Year

Joseph

Honours:

Manager of the year 2010

Hall of Fame Points: 1

Sackings: 3

League Positions:
2010 Bolton 9th Prem
2011 Bolton 11th Prem
2012 Bolton 20th Prem
2013 Newcastle 19th Prem
2014 Wolves 10th Prem
2015 Wolves 11th Prem
2016 Wolves 15th Prem
2017 Wolves 6th Prem
2018 Wolves 12th Prem


Geir

Honours:

2013 Premier League Runners Up
2014 Premier League Champions
2014 Europa League Winners
2014 FA Cup Winners
2014 Charity Shield Winners
2014 European Super Cup Runners Up
2018 Premier League Champions
2018 Charity Shield Winners

2013 Manager of the Year
2014 Manager of the Year

Hall of Fame Points: 34

Sackings: 2

2010 Wigan 13th Prem
2011 Wigan 19th Prem
2012 West Ham 10th Prem
2013 West Ham 2nd Prem
2014 West Ham 1st Prem
2015 West Ham 4th Prem
2016 West Ham 3rd Prem
2017 West Ham 5th Prem
2018 West Ham 1st Prem

Kimberley

Honours:

2012 League Cup Winners
2014 Europa League Runners-Up
2015 Premier League Winners
2015 Europa League Winners
2015 European Super Cup Winners
2016 FA Cup Winners
2016 Premier League Runners-Up
2017 Europa League Winners
2017 European Super Cup Runners-UP
2018 Premier League Runners-Up
2018 FA Cup Runners-Up

2015 Manager of the Year
2016 Manager of the Year

Hall of Fame Points: 40

Sackings: 1

2010 Hull 15th Prem
2011 Hull 16th Prem
2012 Hull 14th Prem
2013 Hull 7th Prem
2014 Hull 6th Prem
2015 Hull 1st Prem
2016 Hull 2nd Prem
2017 Man Utd 3rd Prem
2018 Man Utd 2nd Prem

Steve

Honours:

2013 FA Cup Winners
2014 Premier League Runners-Up
2015 FA Cup Runners-up
2016 FA Cup Runners-up
2018 FA Cup Winners
2018 League Cup Runners-up

2011 Manager of the Year
2012 Manager of the Year

Hall of Fame Points: 17

Sackings: 2

2010 Wolves 16th Prem
2011 Wolves 13th Prem
2012 Wolves 6th Prem
2013 Wolves 8th Prem
2014 Chelsea 2nd Prem
2015 Chelsea 3rd Prem
2016 Chelsea 8th Prem (sacked)
2017 Chelsea 8th Prem (sacked)
2017 Sunderland 8th Prem
2018 Sunderland 6th Prem

Belly

Honours:
None

Hall of Fame Points: 0

Sackings: 4

2010 Fulham 17th Prem
2011 Fulham 17th Prem
2012 Fulham 18th Prem (sacked)
2012 Stoke 13th Prem
2013 Stoke 14th Prem
2014 Stoke 13th Prem
2015 Stoke 18th Prem (sacked)
2016 Portsmouth 17th Prem
2017 Portsmouth 12th Prem
2018 Portsmouth 10th Prem

Johannes

Honours:
None

Hall of Fame Points: 0

Sackings: 0

2010 Blackburn 10th Prem
2011 Blackburn 11th Prem
2012 Blackburn 8th Prem
2013 Blackburn 10th Prem - left halfway through season

George

Honours:
None
Hall of Fame points: 0

Sackings: 0

2010 Sunderland 12th Prem

Stuart

Honours:
2018 FA Cup winners
2018 Europa League Runners-up

Hall of Fame Points: 7

Sackings: 4

2010 Stoke 18th Prem (Sacked)
2011 Middlesbrough 20th Prem
2012 Sunderland 9th Prem
2013 Sunderland 13th Prem
2014 Sunderland 12th Prem
2015 Sunderland 7th Prem
2016 Sunderland 9th Prem
2017 Aston Villa 13th Prem
2018 Aston Villa 13th Prem

Jack

Honours:
None

Hall of Fame Points: 0

Sackings: 3

Hall of Fame Points: 0

2013 Blackburn 11th Prem
2014 Blackburn 17th Prem
2015 Blackburn 14th Prem
2016 Blackburn 12th Prem
2017 Blackburn 16th Prem (resigned before the end of the season)
2018 Southend 16th Prem

Mike

Honours:

2017 League Cup Winners
2017 Premier League Winners
2017 Charity Shield Winners
2018 League Cup Winners
2018 Champions League Winners
2018 European Super Cup Winners
2018 World Club Cup Winners

Hall of Fame Points: 29

Sackings: 0

2014 Wigan 15th Prem
2015 Wigan 10th Prem
2016 Wigan 7th Prem
2017 Wigan 1st Prem
2018 Wigan 5th Prem

Jimmy

Honours:
None

Hall of Fame Points: 0

Sackings: 1

2015 West Bromich 17th Prem
2016 West Bromich 11th Prem
2017 West Bromich 7th Prem
2018 West Bromich 7th Prem

Dave

Honours:
None

Hall of Fame Points: 0

Sackings: 0

2012 West Bromich 15th Prem
2013 West Bromich 15th Prem
2014 West Bromich 14th Prem

Oliver

Honours:
None

Hall of Fame Points: 0

Sackings: 1

2016 Ipswich 16th Prem
2017 Ipswich 14th Prem
2018 Ipswich 4th Prem




Hall of Fame Rankings:

Kim: 40
Geir: 34
Mike: 29
Steve: 17
Stuart: 7
Joe: 1

Amendment to jack:

2017 Blackburn 16th Prem (sacked midway through season)
2017 Stoke 18th Prem (sacked)

I missed off Mike's 2 manager of the year awards!

So he has:

2017 Manager of the Year
2018 Manager of the Year

Hall of Fame points: 31